Let’s delve into the realm of automated teller machines (ATMs).
While many of us simply swipe our cards and withdraw cash without a second thought, there’s a whole world of intricacies behind the scenes. This includes the languages they communicate in, the alliances they form, and the complex web of fees involved at every level.
If you’ve ever been curious about the economics and inner workings of ATMs, or if you’re interested in investing in them, this edition is tailored for you.
Discover:
– The origins of the ATM.
– The rapid expansion of ATMs.
– How lesser-known ATMs establish communication with your bank.
– Insight into Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) networks.
– The major EFT networks that fly under the radar.
– The revenue model behind surcharge-free ATMs.
– The concept of ATM alliances.
– Leading companies in the ATM alliance space.
– Investment opportunities in the ATM sector.
– Costs associated with purchasing ATM machines.
– Challenges faced in ATM investment.
– Speculations on the future of ATMs.
– Introduction to Interactive Teller Machines (ITMs) and Reverse ATMs.
– Understanding “Cashless” ATMs and their legality.
Let’s delve into the realm of automated teller machines (ATMs).
While many of us simply swipe our cards and withdraw cash without a second thought, there’s a whole world of intricacies behind the scenes. This includes the languages they communicate in, the alliances they form, and the complex web of fees involved at every level. If you’ve ever been curious about the economics and inner workings of ATMs, or if you’re interested in investing in them, this edition is tailored for you.
When we discuss advancements in finance, the spotlight often shines on topics like digital banking, cryptocurrencies, or innovative fundraising methods such as Regulation CF or Regulation A. However, one seemingly mundane technology has arguably wielded a more profound influence on financial services than any other: the ATM.
Since its inception in 1967, the ATM has reshaped the way people interact with banking services. It liberated individuals from the confines of traditional bank branches, enabling transactions outside of regular banking hours and locations. Today, the concept of withdrawing cash without setting foot in a physical bank seems archaic, with many individuals, myself included, having eschewed bank branches for years.
The automation of banking services and the detachment of currency from its physical origins represented a monumental shift in the financial landscape, particularly notable in the wake of the Global Financial Crisis. It prompted former Federal Reserve Chair Paul Volcker to famously remark, “The ATM has been the only useful innovation in banking for the past 20 years.”
The question of the ATM’s inventor is subject to debate. While the widely accepted narrative credits British engineer John Shepherd-Barron with the idea, reality reveals a more complex lineage. Shepherd-Barron’s bathtub epiphany, though charming, is just part of the story. The ATM’s development involved multiple projects, including the Bankograph by Luther Simjian and James Goodfellow’s patent for a PIN-based cash machine. Ultimately, Shepherd-Barron’s team installed the first modern ATM at a Barclays branch in London in 1967, marking a pivotal moment in banking history.
The proliferation of ATMs in the 1980s and 1990s was staggering. From a mere 1,500 machines globally in the early 1970s, ATMs experienced exponential growth, with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 24.2% over three decades. Convenience undoubtedly played a role, but economic factors were equally significant. As societies became wealthier, cash usage declined, and electronic wage payments became the norm. Consequently, ATMs became essential conduits for accessing cash, especially in countries where cashless transactions were on the rise.
However, there are limits to this trend. In affluent societies where cash usage diminishes, the value proposition of ATMs weakens. Consequently, high-income countries have witnessed a decline in ATM numbers in recent years, reflecting broader shifts towards cashless economies.
The process of withdrawing cash from an ATM may seem straightforward—insert your card, input your banking details, withdraw cash, and await the deduction from your account. However, beneath this apparent simplicity lies a web of intricacies that raise several fundamental questions:
At the heart of this system are Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) networks, which serve as the linchpin connecting banks to authenticate and verify transactions. Consider a scenario where you seek to withdraw cash from an ATM operated by a bank different from your own. Through a shared EFT network, your bank communicates with the ATM operator’s bank to confirm the availability of funds for the transaction. Upon approval, your bank disburses the cash, and settlement between the banks occurs subsequently.
The complexity escalates when dealing with non-bank ATM operators, known as Independent ATM Deployers (IADs). Since these entities lack direct access to EFT networks, they must secure sponsorship from larger banks to facilitate transactions. Consequently, when you use an IAD ATM, the sponsoring bank acts as an intermediary, relaying the transaction request through the EFT network to your bank for authorization or denial.
EFT networks serve as the universal language facilitating communication among ATMs worldwide. While banks are fluent in this language, IADs rely on sponsor banks to translate and access the network. Moreover, there exist international networks like Cirrus (owned by Mastercard) and Plus (owned by Visa), spanning the globe, alongside domestic networks tailored to specific countries or regions such as Accel, STAR, NYCE, MoneyPass, and Allpoint in North America.
For consumers, possessing a debit card bearing the Mastercard or Visa logo grants access to a vast network of ATMs worldwide, thanks to the expansive reach of Cirrus and Plus. Historically content with their role in facilitating transactions and earning fees, EFT networks have recently emerged as proponents of fee-free ATMs, reshaping the landscape of ATM accessibility.
The proliferation of ATM fees has elicited strong aversion from users, with nearly 80% actively seeking to avoid them. This sentiment has grown more pronounced over time, especially as ATM fees continue to climb. Consequently, offering surcharge-free ATM access has become a significant competitive advantage for banks.
Traditionally, banks furnish ATMs as a benefit to their account holders, while Independent ATM Deployers (IADs) operate ATMs as a business endeavor. Consequently, using one’s own bank’s ATM typically incurs no fees, whereas utilizing an unaffiliated ATM often results in charges.
Enter the concept of ATM alliances—a solution particularly beneficial for smaller banks unable to afford a nationwide network of proprietary ATMs. These alliances allow participating banks’ account holders to access ATMs within the network free of charge. Leveraging existing infrastructure, Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) networks, which already interconnect banks, are ideally positioned to facilitate these alliances.
Companies like Allpoint and Moneypass, originally conceived as networks, have transitioned into owning or operating tens of thousands of fee-free ATMs across the United States. Through alliances with member banks, these networks provide widespread access to surcharge-free ATMs, collectively comprising a substantial portion of all ATMs nationwide.
Rather than directly charging users, these companies generate revenue by receiving payments from banks, typically on a per-transaction basis. Nevertheless, fee-charging ATMs persist globally, presenting potential lucrative business opportunities, particularly in prime locations.
As society’s financial landscape evolves, so too do automated teller machines (ATMs), adapting to meet changing consumer needs and technological advancements.
Interactive Teller Machines (ITMs)
Acknowledging the diminishing relevance of traditional ATMs due to declining cash and check usage, some banks are embracing Interactive Teller Machines (ITMs). ITMs facilitate live video chats between customers and remote tellers, enabling more complex transactions such as loan inquiries and account openings. This innovative approach not only enhances customer service but also reduces costs for banks by potentially replacing costly domestic tellers with more economical overseas counterparts.
Reverse ATMs
In contrast to conventional ATMs where customers insert cards to withdraw cash, reverse ATMs operate in the opposite manner. Customers deposit cash into these machines and receive prepaid cards usable only at the location housing the kiosk. This solution caters to businesses seeking to accommodate cash transactions while avoiding the logistical challenges and security risks associated with handling physical currency.
Cashless ATMs
While the term “cashless ATM” may initially seem contradictory, this technology serves a unique purpose, originally emerging in the cannabis industry. Due to federal restrictions, many dispensaries struggle to process sales through traditional payment networks. Cashless ATMs offer a workaround by coding transactions as ATM withdrawals, allowing dispensaries to accept electronic payments while disguising the nature of the transaction. This method has since extended beyond the cannabis sector, with various legitimate businesses utilizing cashless ATMs to sidestep credit card processing fees.
Cash Registers as ATMs
As businesses increasingly prioritize digital payments and view cash handling as cumbersome and costly, innovative solutions are emerging to streamline transactions. One such approach involves transforming cash registers into pseudo-ATMs, offering customers the option to receive cash back during purchases, akin to the cash-back feature commonly available at grocery stores. Startups like Spare, supported by investors such as Mark Cuban, are spearheading efforts to implement this feature across a wide range of retail establishments, further blurring the lines between traditional banking and retail operations.
In essence, the evolution of ATMs reflects broader shifts in consumer preferences and technological advancements, with innovative solutions emerging to enhance convenience, efficiency, and security in financial transactions.
Investing in ATMs is a form of real asset investing: you own a share of a large group of physical machines. Funds that hold thousands of ATMs spread the results across many machines and locations, which can smooth out the ups and downs of any single machine.
The income comes from transaction fees, and investors have no part in running the machines. As with any investment, cash flow is not guaranteed and investors can lose money.
ATMs are equipment, so they depreciate faster than real estate. Depreciation passes through to investors, and bonus depreciation rules may allow a large share of it in the first year. How much of that you can use depends on your other passive income and your tax situation, so ask your CPA.
Most investors get exposure through a fund instead of buying machines directly. These funds usually have a set holding period, often around seven years, and many pay distributions monthly or quarterly. The investor provides capital and has no operating duties.
What investors look at when reviewing an ATM fund:
Lane Kawaoka, PE, is the founder of The Wealth Elevator and the author of two Amazon bestselling books, The Wealth Elevator and Simple Passive Cashflow. He spent 12 years as an engineer, bought his first rental in 2009, and left his job in 2019. He built his base in real estate and today is a general partner, operator and fund manager working with a community of accredited investors across real estate, oil and gas, and private companies. His track record: $2.1B of past real estate acquisitions, 10,000+ units acquired, 65+ projects, and $230M+ raised.
This site is free education for accredited investors and high-income professionals whose net worth sits mostly in stocks, a 401(k) and a salary. Start with the guides, the podcast or an event.
This is educational content, not tax, legal, or investment advice. We are not attorneys, CPAs, or financial planners. Please let us know if you need a referral to a CPA, lawyer, or other vendor here.